Design flaws & improvements

Ask a cyclist what aspects of cycle infrastructure design are hindering a safe, smooth, fast or enjoyable ride, and you get a long list of flaws that could have been prevented on the drawing board. They have experienced, among other things, shared use of pavements, small cycle lanes, sheep pens, guardrails, dark coloured posts in shared paths, lack of or inappropriate junction provision and multiple lane crossings.

Sadly, even with the new design advice in place (Cycle Infrastructure Design – LTN 1/20), we find examples of breaches in design standards and other historic design flaws in the Taunton area.

06/05/2025

Discriminatory barriers on cycle lanes

Barriers are prevalent on cycle paths in Somerset and they appear to be increasing. Their use is in breach of government design guidance (LTN 1/20) and are restrictive to people who use adaptive bicycles, cargo cycles and bicycles with tag along trailers. The barriers fail to meet legal obligations under the Equality Act 2010 and in particular represent a failure to make reasonable adjustments in order to not discriminate against disabled people.

We have been compiling an inventory of problematical barriers in the Taunton area and found over 50 locations which we have meticulously mapped and described
If you have problems with any barriers, please email us with the location.

A good example of these barriers can be found in the new housing development at Killams. There are some good paths and the estate entry sign suggests that cycling is encouraged. But the paths are littered with barriers.

Our recommendation

We appeal to Somerset Council to comply with design guidance LTN 1/20 and avoid the use of physical restrictions on paths.

Entry sign to Killams seems to welcome cycling.
28/04/2025

Aldi Bathpool cycle and pedestrian path danger

TACC has asked Somerset Council twice for low cost safety improvements at the entrance to Aldi, Bathpool on Bridgwater Road. There is no give-way marking or stop line before the cycle/pedestrian path, there are no cycle logos in the cycle space to indicate to motorists that the route is continuous and no signs warning drivers coming in and out of the presence of the cycle path crossing. The YouTube video clearly shows the conflict here.

The crossing was provided at part of the Creech Castle road scheme in 2022. The design breaches both the Department for Transport Note LTN 1/20 (10.13) guidance to local authorities, that the cycle and pedestrian path across a side crossing should be continuous and the Highway Code that gives priority to pedestrians and cyclists at side roads.

Unwilling Somerset Council

TACC representatives met a consultant employed by Somerset County Council on site and asked for improvements for cyclists as soon as the path was opened in 2022. They were told that though there was available budget, the Council’s Stage 3 safety audit raised no safety issues and no action would be taken. TACC asked for a copy of the audit but this was refused on the basis that it has not been signed off by the designer and would not be for some time. The conflict shown in the YouTube video illustrates why TACC disagrees with the conclusion of the safety audit. The strategies adopted by people walking and cycling range from extreme caution to a certain level of risk taking.

TACC has also approached Aldi. In December 2024 their representatives acknowledged the issue and apologised for the inconvenience to pedestrians and cyclists. They asked for suggestions which TACC provided. We suggested a range of straight forward and easy to implement measures, including the type of signing and markings used on the exit to Tesco to the A3807 in Taunton. Here the give way marking has been pulled back behind the cycle path and a warning sign is provided.

Our recommendation

We urge the Council to do the necessary work to make the entrance safer for cyclists and pedestrians and to ensure motorists are aware that the cycle route crossing has priority. The Council should also refrain from allowing or building any more unsafe cycle crossings like this, ensure future cyclepaths are continuous rather than stop start and adhere to the design guide LTN 1/20.

General design issues in Taunton

Let us take you through Taunton and show a number of (preventable) cycling infrastructure design issues.

Oversized roundabouts and multiple lane crossings

Priory Bridge Road Junction (figure 1) is severing retail and jobs from housing. Pedestrians have to cross four lanes of traffic at each crossing point with no protection. Discourages walking and cycling in dense urban areas. Surely a junction of this size is too large for an urban context? Surely a safe and easy to use pedestrian crossing would be more civilised and safer? Imagine someone with walking difficulties trying to cross here when there are high traffic flows. Manual for Streets 2 (9.6.7) says entry and exit widths should be as narrow as possible.

Similar approach at Monkton Heathfield, again creating barriers to walking/cycling (figure 2). Do entries and exits into/from the junction need to be so wide, taking into account paragraph 9.6.7 in MfS2?

This roundabout layout (figure 3) is more equitable in providing for motor vehicles, pedestrians and cyclists. Crossing points positioned back from the problematical entries/exists and crossing much clearer to motorists. Crossing lengths are reduced.

Lack of priority at side road crossings

People walking and cycling have to defer to cars from a handful of houses on a route to school (figure 4). Every time there is a side road, this problem is replicated. It sends a loud message about the priority accorded to people walking and cycling. MfS2 (9.3.13) states that all crossings can be provided with raised crossing and a detail drawing is provided.

Raised crossings at side road crossings are becoming widespread in the UK (although not in Taunton) following MfS2 advice (figure 5).

The ‘Sheep Pen’

Use of ugly guard railing and sheep pens to herd people were popular with highway engineers in the 1960s. Today many Highway Authorities minimise the use of guard railing. The image (figure 6) shows a new Somerset scheme near North Petherton. However, Department for Transport LTN 2/09 advice is that alternative measures to guard railing should be considered.

Inappropriate junction solutions with pedestrian and cycle crossings positioned off peoples’ desire line

At the new roundabout at Chip Lane, cyclists are required to use a pedestrian crossing to negotiate a road junction. It is completely the wrong design solution on a road in an urban area. The junction should have been designed with traffic signals and cycle priority measures such as lanes, advanced stop lines etc. You can just make out a cyclist negotiating the roundabout (figure 7) – clearly cyclists are not going to use such an inconvenient arrangement, and will instead be at risk of being knocked off by motorized traffic on the roundabout.

Detailed design concerns: dark coloured posts in shared paths

These posts in figure 8 are not very visible in dull/dark conditions and so constitute an obstacle. Their purpose is unclear.

Textured surfaces

Often these are not properly installed and rattle as the user crosses them. Weeds can be seen growing (figure 9) through the gaps on this newish installation at Monkton Heathfield. Over time, water ingress will create problems for users and from a maintenance point of view.

Slabs of this type should be laid on straight lengths. In some cases they are laid on slight bends and this creates a skid risk since they are laid with the lines running longitudinal on the cycling side.

Over signing of cycling infrastructure

These signs (figure 10) do not specifically create user problems but costs could be saved, carbon impact reduced and ugliness avoided. Is it really necessary to have mini forests of signs at a junction?

13/12/2020

Cycle lanes in Taunton still painted

New government policy and design standards advise against painting unprotected cycle lanes on busy traffic streets. Better protected infrastructure is called for. We are therefore baffled as to why Somerset County Council (SCC) has gone into cycle lane painting mode, set out in an article on highwaysindustry.com titled ‘Transport schemes in Somerset to benefit from £15.4m Government funding’, and shown in the images.

This funding will cover a number of schemes, of which three have currently being confirmed, namely red surfacing on some of Taunton’s cycle lanes, widening and resurfacing the cycle routes between Minehead and Carhampton, and strengthening and improving the footpath between Minehead and Williton. We have asked SCC several times what is behind all this, but there is a deafening silence. We’ll keep asking them.

Creech Castle Scheme bollards

On the other side of Creech Castle Junction, the footway on the Aldi side is being widened to allow shared use. The pelican at Bathpool will be a cycle and pedestrian crossing. This is part of the Creech Castle scheme where some of the cycling elements are being implemented earlier. It is substandard in terms of new DfT design guidance but will provide an alternative for a busy road, especially for students at Heathfield school.
But there will be hazardous bollards that SCC seem rather keen on. One person commented on our discussion group Facebook page: “Are they to assist with bunny-hopping over pedestrians?  The sign is right, just in the wrong place – it’s not pointless, just an unnecessary risk where it is. But the scheme sounds like a good compromise – especially for kids on bikes”.

26/03/2023

Lack of provision during works – Firepool as an example

During the works on the new access into Firepool off Trenchard Way in 2023, a long section of Trenchard Way was operating with shuttle traffic signals. A length of the shared footway on the south side of Trenchard Way was rubble, there was no provision for cycling and no information on how cyclists were supposed to get through the area. We have tried riding with the traffic several times. On one occasion, traffic was coming towards us in the narrow section before we were able to ride through, with a huge amount of impatient traffic behind us. The signal timings didn’t allow sufficient time for cyclists to clear the section affected. When we got to the end, we were pretty desperate to rejoin the shared footway, but Somerset County Council (SCC) had made no provision to do that, so we were stuck on the carriageway.

Our recommendation to the council

We sent a sketch proposal to Somerset County Council (SCC) asking that cyclists be allowed to use the footway on a temporary basis with priority to pedestrians, utilising the crossings at each end of the works. This was based on observing what most people seem to be doing, without problem.

Somerset County Council replied as follows: “We have worked closely with the contractor to consider all temporary traffic management options, regrettably due to the lack of available width and the need to balance the needs of all users, it is not possible in this instance to safely accommodate cyclists through the temporary layout. Cyclists are therefore advised to dismount at either end of the works and follow the pedestrian route along the north side.”

In our response, we pointed out that it would take several minutes to walk along the footway, a significant time penalty and an unpleasant experience. Not surprisingly most cyclists cycled on the footway. The combined flows are low so we asked SCC again to formalise this on a temporary basis, with priority for pedestrians. SCC was not willing to cooperate.

A member of the public commented: “Somerset County Council make bold claims that they are encouraging Active Transport. This project is another example where cyclists have not even been considered as an afterthought before closing part of Trenchard Way Cycle path. There was no advance or current signage posted warning of the closure, nor has any reasonable provision been made to encourage cyclists to continue using the route during the necessary works. Not encouraging Active Transport! We also have no idea how long the closure will be, and more importantly, the Council plans for the ‘lost’ part of the cycle path after the completed work. These issues could easily be avoided if the Council and their contractors engaged with TACC and cyclists.”
24/06/2022

Somerset County Council apologises for errors

Somerset County Council (SCC) has apologised after officers failed to consult and carry out a risk assessment for changes to a junction in central Taunton. In early 2021, SCC introduced a dedicated left turn filter lane to increase capacity to cars on the Castle Street/Wellington Road junction. This put cyclists going ahead to the Wellington road cycle provision in conflict with left turning traffic.

Initially, SCC ignored representations from individual cyclists and the hazard was in place for nearly a year. When TACC approached them, the problem was resolved. A Freedom of Information Act request revealed that the original changes were made without consultation and a risk assessment. We feel that this showed a disregard for safety of vulnerable road users.