A358 Taunton-Ilminster

The A303/A358 corridor is a vital connection between the South West and London and the South East. While much of the corridor is a dual carriageway, there are still over 35 miles of single carriageway. These sections act as congestion bottlenecks, particularly in the summer months and at weekends, causing delays to road users, and they add to an increased risk of accidents.

30/08/2024

A358 Taunton to Southfields Scheme Cancelled

Following the Government’s budget announcement on 30 October 2024, the A358 Taunton to Southfields scheme has been cancelled. The scheme was identified as having poor value for money and limited economic benefits for the region. National Highways have been instructed to remove the Route Protection in place for the A358 Taunton to Southfields scheme. The A358 will remain a Somerset Council Road, and they will be responsible for addressing any ongoing concerns or challenges on the route.

Source: nationalhighways.co.uk

28/06/2022

A358 scheme still ignores direct and safe cycling route

Three years ago, TACC submitted a petition to National Highways (NH) with three asks on their A358 dualling scheme. The three asks, and NH’s response, are as follows:

  • A quality cycle track between Ilminster and Taunton. NH are proposing a convoluted and relatively hilly ‘off line’ route which will be shared with traffic. This is way short of what should be provided.
  • Safe and attractive crossing to A358/Junction 25 at the M5 – a bridge or a tunnel. NH have actually back tracked on their earlier proposed improvements.
  • Confirmation that wherever the road cuts across quiet rural lanes, safe crossings will be provided. NH are proposing two traffic free bridge crossings on the southern section of the route. But one of the most popular crossings at Mattocks Tree Green is proposed to become very hostile for active travel.

Despite working constructively with the National Highways Project Team throughout the Consultation Process, the cycling provision in the Supplementary Consultation of June 2022 falls well short of the direct and safe quality strategic cycling route the £350m scheme should provide (especially given DfT policy and design guidance ‘Gear Change’).

TACC accepted that the ‘offline’ option proposed by NH potentially had some benefits on some sections, but the proposed offline cycle route meanders both horizontally and vertically compared with the more direct alignment of the A358. Given that NH propose to ban cycling on the A358, this is unfair and creates an in-built bias against active travel and in favour of carbon based transport.

Also, if ringfenced funding and a legal agreement for improvement work on Somerset Highways roads is not in place, we do not believe these will be delivered. These must address safety concerns on the existing Henlade-Thornfalcon dual carriageway section and the A358 at Horton Cross.

However, if agreement cannot be found between National Highways & Somerset County Council on who will fund the offline sections then the only option is to return to the parallel cycle track proposal, which contrary to NH’s assertion, would not sever the local cycling network or the NCN route, as it would be accessible at each of the proposed crossings.

Modest changes by NH do not address main issues

NH has completely ignored the current and projected growth of e-bikes and their potential for longer journeys between settlements with benefits that modal shift brings.

The modest changes made after the Statutory Consultation of November 2021 are welcome and reduce cycling network severance, but do not address many of the issues, including delivering a good quality Ilminster-Taunton strategic cycle route (in particular the offline sections), safety – especially at Mattocks Tree Green junction and at Southfields roundabout – and a comprehensive solution for cyclists crossing M5 Junction 25.

Based on this, we are objecting to the project on the basis of inadequate cycle provision. We are willing to work with NH on the lead up to the Public Examination, to agree a much improved solution. This work needs to address the specific issues we have outlined to them.

We will continue to lobby for a better solution that TACC can support.

Matt Day, Mike Ginger & Jonathan Sladden
TACC representatives

Old Somerser road sign with A358 on it
Photo: National Highways

About the A358 Taunton-Southfields Scheme

Currently most of the A358 is a single lane and has many local roads and private accesses joining directly with it. It’s often congested and is a source of frustration for local people, and those using the road to travel longer distances. Many road users try to avoid the traffic congestion by diverting onto smaller local roads, which then increases the level of traffic in surrounding villages.

To address this, National Highways proposed to upgrade an 8.5 mile section of the A358 between Southfields Roundabout on the A303 and the M5 at Taunton, to a high quality dual carriageway. In 2019 Highways made their preferred route announcement for the improvement scheme, confirming that they are taking a modified version of the pink option forward.

Source: National Highways A358 Scheme

03/07/2018

Petition about A358 scheme presented to Highways England

Our petition calling for proper cycle provision, as part of Highways England’s A358 scheme, was presented to Highways England in Bristol. More than 600 signatures were collected in the spring of 2018. The Regional Director, Nick Aldworth was due to receive it, but was called to Parliament to meet six South West MPs. Instead, we presented the petition to the Communications Manager Karen Duffet. The petition asks as part of Highways England’s £250-£450m scheme to upgrade the A358 for:

  1. a quality cycletrack between Ilminster and Taunton;
  2. safe and attractive crossing to A358/Junction 25 at the M5 – a bridge or a tunnel;
  3. confirmation that wherever the road cuts across quiet rural lanes, safe crossings will be provided.

Our suggestions are in line with Highways England’s own Cycling Strategy from 2016. Highways England have a dedicated cycle budget of at least £100m.

We were told that, among other things, the project team were looking into a separate budget they have access to, in order to make walking and cycling provision. There are likely to be follow up discussions once they announce their ‘preferred route’ and we will be demanding that this takes place.

MP for Taunton supports petition A358

On 20 April 2018, supporters of TACC met Rebecca Pow MP at her office to ask her to present its online petition to the Secretary of State for Transport and Highways England. She agreed that she will pass on our A358 call to the Secretary of State and write to the Regional Director of Highways England in support, and also to Somerset County Council regarding Junction 25.

Pip Sheard, spokesperson for TACC, said: “The A358 is a terrifying road to use. Why should people have to be terrified in order to take a simple cycle journey? Instead, a cycletrack along the A358 could become part of the National Cycle Network benefiting families and children, as well as day to day cycling. We are very pleased to have Ms Pow’s support for our petition.”

Supporters of TACC showing petition at Taunton Station
Supporters of TACC showing petition at Taunton Station
30/01/2018

Highways England’s A358 proposals – little on offer for cycling

Highways England (HE) consulted on route options for the A358 Expressway in 2018. It concerned plans to spend around £300m but there is little on offer for people wanting to use their cycles. There is the  golden opportunity of providing a direct quality link between Ilminster and Taunton. It was an opportunity to substantially improve the situation for walking and cycling at J25, whether in the form of a bridge or tunnel. TACC commented in response to this A358 consultation.

  • Good quality cycling infrastructure should be an essential feature of the scheme: to protect existing lanes/routes, deal with the barrier effect of existing A358 and provide real improvements in the cycling network.
  • There is latent demand to cycle Ilminster-Taunton. Existing road are very hostile. Safe route within A358 corridor needed with a cyclepath running alongside the new road. Pink option could enable space to be provided on the old road on the northern section. The HE are proposing to signpost country lanes as an alternative to the A358. These lanes get very dirty in the winter and aren’t always safe. HE should provide a purpose built path (especially as they will probably try to ban cycling on the A358).
  • Issues of crossing A358 for Horse riders, cyclists and pedestrians. Locations include: Ilton -Broadway; Ilton-Ashill; Ashill-Stawley; Battens Green-Caplan; Hatch Beauchamp-Bickenhill; Ash Cross; Ruishdon-Henlade. Improved, safer crossings are needed. Page 16 of the brochure suggests that some of these locations will be addressed with bridge crossings and this should be confirmed as a commitment from HE.
  • On the pink route, there is an inconsistency between the text in page 11 which says local road crossings will be bridges, and the diagram which raises doubts by using the word ’ possible’. Crossings should be provided and safe crossings will be needed at junctions B and C for walking, cycling, horse riding in line with IAN 195 in relation to cycling provision.
  • On the orange and blue routes routes there is an inconsistency between the text which says local road crossings will be bridges at Ash Cross, Stoke Hill, Shoreditch, Stoke Road, and the diagram which raises doubts by using the word ’possible’. Crossings should be provided and safe crossings will be needed at junctions D and E for walking, cycling, horse riding in line with IAN 195 for cycling provision.
  • A major issue will be a provision of a direct sustainable transport link between Taunton and Nexus, avoiding a series of crossings and convoluted route, as proposed by SCC. The A358 proposal should be seen as an opportuntiy to address this link.
  • In the pink and blue options there will need to be a crossing for people walking and cycling from Ruishton to the Nexus site.
  • The Park and Ride site is not recognised in the proposals and it is unclear how the Park and Ride will be accessed in the pink and blue options.
  • The highway strategy upon which the proposal is based, is flawed:
  1. We have been advised that the planned capacity of this new road is vastly greater than even the projected demand. The forecast 2 way flow in 2038 is 26,000, well below the 32,000 theoretical capacity for a single carriageway road, showing that a dual carriageway with 64,000 capacity would be a vast over provision.
  2. The extra traffic it would induce in the Taunton catchment area would place significant extra traffic on the Taunton network, to the detriment of non-motorised users, such as cyclists.
  3. The Benefit Cost Ratios (BCRs) on all 3 options are poor, ranging 1.64 to 2.08. It is supposed to be a government requirement that the BCR is a minimum of 2 i.e. the benefits (the monetised value of motorists time savings ) are double the construction costs of the road.  Costs will inevitably increase, so the actual BCRs will be less in practice. BCRs ignore environmental costs.
  4. While we recognise the strategic desire for a second motorway/expressway link to the south west peninsula, none of the A358 options provides the desired network reliability to the south west, as the M5 between Taunton and the A30/A38 west of Exeter would be the single motorway route to the peninsula. In the event of an incident on the M5 west of Taunton leading to the closure of one or both carriageways, the impact on local roads would be hugely detrimental, not least to cyclists. Incidents are fairly commonplace.
  • A quality cycling network could be constructed in Taunton at a fraction of this cost, and would bring huge health and traffic function benefits, with vastly better benefit-cost ratios than this scheme offers.
  • If HE do decide to plough ahead with this scheme, the pink option is preferred. It appears to impose lowest environmental damage and gives greatest relief to Henlade. There will need to be traffic management measures to discourage through traffic from using the old road. This could include cycle provision and bus priority measures.
Pink Route showing route options between Henlade and Taunton
Pink Route showing route options between Henlade and Taunton